Moe's Rule
Hilzoy writes at Obsidian Wings:
I think it's time I enforced Moe's Rule upon myself. It's no9 secret that I've been angry for a few days, and here's why:
the reason I've been agry since the Iraqi elections is because of the way that the Left has been characterized in reaction to it.
Look, I am a liberal. I am a classical liberal and a progressive., I am not a Democrat, but social issues are my priority and on that scale the Democrats are much closer to my own (heavily religiously-inspired) views.
In other words, I am on the Left.
Moe's Rule, in effect at ObWi, is "no generalizations about Left or Right". I think we shoud extend that to "conservatives" and "liberals". Since my goal here is to create a new "purple" identity, this is a responsibility I must accept willingly.
I hope my fellow posters here at Dean Nation follow my lead, but this is really a personal thing. I am angry this week because of how I have been treated, by people whose opinion I respect at Red State and elsewhere. I can't let myself mete the same injustice. From this post onwards, it's Moe's Rule for me. I hope the rest of you call me on it if I transgress!
when people talk about "the Left", who, exactly, do they have in mind? I have no idea. And I suspect that the idea that there is something called 'the Left' which is large enough to be worth talking about is often simply a figment of the various writers' imaginations, and that they can only believe this 'Left' to be a real, significant group because they do not force themselves to identify who they are talking about more precisely. If they were precise, they would (I think) have to conclude either that 'the Left' is a tiny group of people, or that much of what they say about it is not true. But because they are not, they can say all sorts of things about it without ever running the risk of being proved wrong.
I think it's time I enforced Moe's Rule upon myself. It's no9 secret that I've been angry for a few days, and here's why:
the reason I've been agry since the Iraqi elections is because of the way that the Left has been characterized in reaction to it.
Look, I am a liberal. I am a classical liberal and a progressive., I am not a Democrat, but social issues are my priority and on that scale the Democrats are much closer to my own (heavily religiously-inspired) views.
In other words, I am on the Left.
Moe's Rule, in effect at ObWi, is "no generalizations about Left or Right". I think we shoud extend that to "conservatives" and "liberals". Since my goal here is to create a new "purple" identity, this is a responsibility I must accept willingly.
I hope my fellow posters here at Dean Nation follow my lead, but this is really a personal thing. I am angry this week because of how I have been treated, by people whose opinion I respect at Red State and elsewhere. I can't let myself mete the same injustice. From this post onwards, it's Moe's Rule for me. I hope the rest of you call me on it if I transgress!
Comments