Everydayborday is Labor Day
Ezra Klein is determined to pay more attention to Labor issues, especially with the great fight ahead to unionize WalMart. Note that demonizing Wal-Mart is not the key here - as laborGuru Nathan Newman notes:
Or, more succinctly by Matthew Yglesias:
Quite so. The important point is that corporations provide jobs too. Equalizing the playing field of wages and benefits will mean that a job at Wal Mart and a job at Mom-N-Pop's Inc. will have the same "value", to both society and to the laborer. The rising tide that floats all boats is the direction we need to go. This view also largely informs my stance on illegal immigration, but that's for another time (though I would like to see Ezra and Matt and Nathan address immigration from a Labor standpoint too, given their vastly superor expertise in this regard than mine).
In the meantime, I shop at WalMart without shame for much the same reason. WalMart *will* be forced to unionize eventually (though we might have to wait for Hillary's era).
Wal-Mart is no doubt here to stay as part of the fabric of our economy. But just as the anti-union auto corporations of the 1920s were forced to improve job conditions for their workers in the 1930s and 1940s by a combination of legislation and union organizing, so too must we work to force Wal-Mart to become a responsible employer that is a net contributor to labor standards, and not a drain on our public resources.
Or, more succinctly by Matthew Yglesias:
Give me a unionized WalMart with decent labor policies, and I'll happily let the colossus stamp out America's mom and pop stores if that's what the market demands.
Quite so. The important point is that corporations provide jobs too. Equalizing the playing field of wages and benefits will mean that a job at Wal Mart and a job at Mom-N-Pop's Inc. will have the same "value", to both society and to the laborer. The rising tide that floats all boats is the direction we need to go. This view also largely informs my stance on illegal immigration, but that's for another time (though I would like to see Ezra and Matt and Nathan address immigration from a Labor standpoint too, given their vastly superor expertise in this regard than mine).
In the meantime, I shop at WalMart without shame for much the same reason. WalMart *will* be forced to unionize eventually (though we might have to wait for Hillary's era).
Comments